Difference between revisions of "User:Erisceres/O'Nolan's Introduction to Studies in Modern Irish"

From Celtic Languages
Jump to navigationJump to search
 
(12 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
= Lesson I: Classification Sentences Using Masculine Nouns and Pronouns with the Copula and an Indefinite Predicate =
= Lesson I: Classification Clauses with Masculine Nouns =


'''Key:''' {{color|Red|'''{{smallcaps|⟨copula⟩}}'''}}, {{color|Blue|'''{{smallcaps|⟨predicate⟩}}'''}}, {{color|DeepSkyBlue|'''{{smallcaps|⟨subpredicate⟩}}'''}}, {{color|Green|'''{{smallcaps|⟨subject⟩}}'''}}, {{color|LimeGreen|'''{{smallcaps|⟨subsubject⟩}}'''}}.
'''Key:''' {{color|Red|'''{{smallcaps|⟨copula⟩}}'''}}, {{color|Blue|'''{{smallcaps|⟨predicate⟩}}'''}}, {{color|DeepSkyBlue|'''{{smallcaps|⟨subpredicate⟩}}'''}}, {{color|Green|'''{{smallcaps|⟨subject⟩}}'''}}, {{color|LimeGreen|'''{{smallcaps|⟨subsubject⟩}}'''}}.


'''Simple Classification Clauses:'''
The '''copula''' is the element that links the subject to a predicate. Here, the affirmative form of the copula in the present tense is ''{{color|Red|is}}''.


In simple classification syntax, the '''indefinite predicate''' follows immediately after the '''copula''', and precedes the '''subject''' '''⟨{{color|Red|C}}{{color|Blue|P}}{{color|Green|S}}⟩''':
The '''predicate''' is the element that describes the subject. In classification clauses, the predicate is <u>always indefinite</u>; it cannot be a definite noun nor a personal pronoun. Here, the predicate is the masculine noun ''{{color|Blue|leabhar}}'' – “(a) book” <ref group="note">There is no indefinite article in Irish. Without the definite article, ''leabhar'' can mean either “book” or “a book” depending on the context.</ref> – which is the description being used to classify the subject. In copular classification clauses, it is the predicate that carries the syntactical stress.


* ''{{color|Red|Is}} {{color|Blue|leabhar}} {{color|Green|é}}.'' – “It is a book.
The '''subject''' is the element that is being classified. Unless a specific noun is being used to refer to the subject, it is generally referred to with a pronoun. The pronoun itself conforms to the grammatical gender and number of the predicate, being a direct reference to the predicate itself. Where the predicate consists of a singular masculine noun, the singular masculine disjunctive pronoun ''{{color|Green|é}}'' is used for the subject.


The '''copula''' is the element that links the subject to a predicate. Here, the affirmative form of the copula in the present tense is ''{{color|Red|is}}''.
== Simple Classification Clauses ==


The '''predicate''' is the element that describes the subject. In classification clauses, the predicate is <u>always indefinite</u>; it cannot be a definite noun or a personal pronoun. Here, the predicate is the masculine noun ''{{color|Blue|leabhar}}'' – “(a) book” (see [[User:Erisceres/O%27Nolan%27s_Introduction_to_Studies_in_Modern_Irish#Notes|note 1]]) – which is the description being used to classify the subject.
In simple classification syntax, the '''indefinite predicate''' follows immediately after the '''copula''', and precedes the '''subject''' '''⟨{{color|Red|C}}{{color|Blue|P}}{{color|Green|S}}⟩''':


The '''subject''' is the element that is being classified. Unless a specific noun is being used to refer to the subject, it is generally referred to with a pronoun. The pronoun itself conforms to the grammatical gender and number of the predicate, being a direct reference to the predicate itself. Where the predicate consists of a singular masculine noun, the singular masculine disjunctive pronoun ''{{color|Green|é}}'' is used for the subject.
* ''{{color|Red|Is}} {{color|Blue|leabhar}} {{color|Green|é}}.'' – “It is a book.


To form the present negative in classification syntax, the copular form ''{{color|Red|ní}}'' is used:
To form the '''present negative''' in classification syntax, the copular form ''{{color|Red|ní}}'' is used:


* ''{{color|Red|Ní}} {{color|Blue|leabhar}} {{color|Green|é}}.'' – “It is not a book.”
* ''{{color|Red|Ní}} {{color|Blue|leabhar}} {{color|Green|é}}.'' – “It is not a book.”


To form the present interrogative, ''{{color|Red|an}}'' is used:
To form the '''present interrogative''', ''{{color|Red|an}}'' is used:


* ''{{color|Red|An}} {{color|Blue|leabhar}} {{color|Green|é}}?'' – “Is it a book?”
* ''{{color|Red|An}} {{color|Blue|leabhar}} {{color|Green|é}}?'' – “Is it a book?”


== Questions with Simple Responses ==
A response to such a question doesn't repeat the '''predicate''' or '''subject'''. Rather, the '''indefinite subpredicate pronoun''' – ''{{color|DeepSkyBlue|ea}}'' – is employed '''⟨{{color|Red|C}}{{color|DeepSkyBlue|p}}⟩''':
 
A response to such a question doesn't repeat the predicate or subject. Rather, the indefinite subpredicate pronoun – ''{{color|DeepSkyBlue|ea}}'' – is employed '''⟨{{color|Red|C}}{{color|DeepSkyBlue|p}}⟩''':


* —''{{color|Red|An}} {{color|Blue|leabhar}} {{color|Green|é}}?'' – “Is it a book?”
* —''{{color|Red|An}} {{color|Blue|leabhar}} {{color|Green|é}}?'' – “Is it a book?”
Line 32: Line 30:
The negative response would be:
The negative response would be:


* —''{{color|Red|Ní}} {{color|DeepSkyBlue|hea}}.'' – “It isn't.” (see [[User:Erisceres/O%27Nolan%27s_Introduction_to_Studies_in_Modern_Irish#Notes|note 2]])
* —''{{color|Red|Ní}} {{color|DeepSkyBlue|hea}}.'' – “It isn't.” <ref group="note" name="ní hea">The present negative copular form ''ní'' causes ''h''-prothesis on the following word, hence ''hea''.</ref>


Following a negative response, the correct information can be provided with the preceding conjunction ''{{color|Blue|ach}}'' – “but” '''⟨{{color|Red|C}}{{color|DeepSkyBlue|p}}{{color|Blue|P}}⟩''':
Following a negative response, the correct information can be provided with the preceding '''conjunction''' ''{{color|Blue|ach}}'' – “but” '''⟨{{color|Red|C}}{{color|DeepSkyBlue|p}}{{color|Blue|P}}⟩''':


* —''{{color|Red|An}} {{color|Blue|leabhar}} {{color|Green|é sin}}?'' – “Is that a book?” (see [[User:Erisceres/O%27Nolan%27s_Introduction_to_Studies_in_Modern_Irish#Notes|note 3]])
* —''{{color|Red|An}} {{color|Blue|leabhar}} {{color|Green|é sin}}?'' – “Is that a book?” <ref group="note">The subject often employs the demonstratives ''seo'', ''sin'' and ''siúd'' – “this”, “that” and “that yonder”, respectively – by combining them with the subject pronoun.</ref>
* —''{{color|Red|Ní}} {{color|DeepSkyBlue|hea}}, {{color|Blue|ach peann}}.'' – “It isn't, but a pen.”
* —''{{color|Red|Ní}} {{color|DeepSkyBlue|hea}}, {{color|Blue|ach peann}}.'' – “It isn't, but a pen.”


A separate copular element is not employed when the clause is headed by the predicate interrogative pronoun ''{{color|Blue|cad}}'' and no suggestion is offered as to the classification. in this format, the subsubject pronoun ''{{color|LimeGreen|é}}'' – following the predicate interrogative pronoun – refers directly to ''{{color|Green|an rud}}'' in the subject ''{{color|Green|an rud é sin}}'' (''rud'' being a masculine noun), while the ''{{color|Green|é}}'' in the subject refers to the predicate in question '''⟨{{color|Blue|P}}{{color|LimeGreen|s}}{{color|Green|S}}⟩''':
A separate copular element is not employed when the clause is headed by the '''predicate interrogative pronoun''' ''{{color|Blue|cad}}'' and no suggestion is offered as to the classification. in this format, the '''subsubject pronoun''' – ''{{color|LimeGreen|é}}'' – following the '''predicate interrogative pronoun''' – refers directly to ''{{color|Green|an rud}}'' in the '''subject''' ''{{color|Green|an rud é sin}}'' (''rud'' being a masculine noun), while the ''{{color|Green|é}}'' in the '''subject''' refers to the '''predicate''' in question '''⟨{{color|Blue|P}}{{color|LimeGreen|s}}{{color|Green|S}}⟩''':


* —''{{color|Blue|Cad}} {{color|LimeGreen|é}} {{color|Green|an rud é sin}}?'' – “What is it, the thing that that is?” (see [[User:Erisceres/O%27Nolan%27s_Introduction_to_Studies_in_Modern_Irish#Notes|note 4]])
* —''{{color|Blue|Cad}} {{color|LimeGreen|é}} {{color|Green|an rud é sin}}?'' – “What is it, the thing that that is?” <ref group="note">''Cad é an rud é sin?'' – this type of question is used when no suggestion is given as to the classification of the object. It can be translated more simply as “what is that thing?”</ref>
* —''{{color|Red|Is}} {{color|Blue|leabhar}} {{color|Green|é}}.'' – “It is a book.”
* —''{{color|Red|Is}} {{color|Blue|leabhar}} {{color|Green|é}}.'' – “It is a book.”


== Questions with Emphatic Responses ==
== Emphatic Classification Clauses ==


When responding in the negative, the correct information can be given in response by placing emphasis on the predicate as a means of contrasting with the previously suggested information. This is done by placing the predicate before the copula, placing the indefinite subpredicate pronoun in the original predicate position '''⟨{{color|Blue|P}}{{color|Red|C}}{{color|DeepSkyBlue|p}}{{color|Green|S}}⟩''':
When responding in the negative, the correct information can be given in response by placing emphasis on the '''predicate''' as a means of contrasting with the previously suggested information. This is done by placing the '''predicate''' before the '''copula''', placing the '''indefinite subpredicate pronoun''' in the original '''predicate''' position '''⟨{{color|Blue|P}}{{color|Red|C}}{{color|DeepSkyBlue|p}}{{color|Green|S}}⟩''':


* —''{{color|Red|An}} {{color|Blue|leabhar}} {{color|Green|é}}?'' – “Is it a book?”
* —''{{color|Red|An}} {{color|Blue|leabhar}} {{color|Green|é}}?'' – “Is it a book?”
* —''{{color|Red|Ní}} {{color|DeepSkyBlue|hea}}; {{color|Blue|peann}} {{color|Red|is}} {{color|DeepSkyBlue|ea}} {{color|Green|é}}.'' – “It isn't; it is a pen.”
* —''{{color|Red|Ní}} {{color|DeepSkyBlue|hea}}; {{color|Blue|peann}} {{color|Red|is}} {{color|DeepSkyBlue|ea}} {{color|Green|é}}.'' – “It isn't; it is a pen.”


<div class="warningbox">'''Note:'''
Likewise, the true '''predicate''' can be emphasised when multiple options are presented in a question. The '''interrogative predicate pronoun''' ''{{color|Blue|cé acu}}'' <ref group="note">The prepostional pronoun ''acu'' refers to the presented alteratives, ''acu'' generally translating to “which of these is it”.</ref> is used to present multiple alternatives in a question, with the '''conjunction''' ''{{color|Blue|nó}}'' dividing the alternatives:
In this type of syntax where the predicated is headed by the interrogative predicate pronoun ''{{color|blue|cé acu}}'', an alternative is presented, divided by the conjunction ''{{color|blue|}}''; the preceding prepositional pronoun ''{{color|blue|acu}}'' refers to this presented alternative.
 
e.g. ''{{color|Blue|Cé acu leabhar nó peann}} {{color|Green|é seo?}}'' “Is this a book or a pen?”
</div>
 
Likewise, the true predicate can be emphasised when multiple options are presented in a question. The interrogative predicate pronoun ''{{color|Blue|cé acu}}'' is used to present multiple alternatives in a question, with the conjunction ''{{color|Blue|nó}}'' dividing the alternatives:


* —''{{color|Blue|Cé acu leabhar nó peann}} {{color|Green|é seo}}?'' – “Which is this, a book or a pen?”
* —''{{color|Blue|Cé acu leabhar nó peann}} {{color|Green|é seo}}?'' – “Which is this, a book or a pen?”
Line 67: Line 59:
Alternatively, the correct information can be given in a simple format without emphasis
Alternatively, the correct information can be given in a simple format without emphasis
* —''{{color|Red|Ní}} {{color|Blue|leabhar ná peann}} {{color|Green|é}}, {{color|Blue|ach lasán}}.'' – “It is neither a book nor a pen, but a match.”
* —''{{color|Red|Ní}} {{color|Blue|leabhar ná peann}} {{color|Green|é}}, {{color|Blue|ach lasán}}.'' – “It is neither a book nor a pen, but a match.”
<div class="warningbox">
'''Notes on the forms of emphasis:'''<br/>
Text here
</div>


== Vocabulary ==
== Vocabulary ==
Line 72: Line 69:
'''Forms of the Copula:'''
'''Forms of the Copula:'''


* ''is'' – present affirmative
* ''is'' – present affirmative <ref group="note">The present affirmative form of the copula is often dropped in speech, e.g. ''leabhar é'' – “it is a book”.</ref>
* ''ní<sup>H</sup>'' – present negative
* ''ní'' <sup>H</sup> – present negative <ref group="note" name="ní hea"/>
* ''an'' – present interrogative
* ''an'' – present interrogative <ref group="note">The present interrogative form of the copula – ''an'' – should not be confused with ''an'', a form of the definite article, e.g. ''an rud'' – “the thing”.</ref>
 
<div class="warningbox">
'''Note:''' The present affirmative form of the copula is often dropped in speech, e.g. ''leabhar é'' – “it is a book”.
</div>


'''Pronouns:'''
'''Pronouns:'''
Line 87: Line 80:
* ''an rud é'' – “the thing it is” (masc.)
* ''an rud é'' – “the thing it is” (masc.)
* ''ea'' – the indefinite subpredicate pronoun
* ''ea'' – the indefinite subpredicate pronoun
* ''cad … ?'' – “what … ?”
* ''cad … ?'' – “what … ?” <ref group="note" name="cad and cé">It could be said that the copular is already contained within interrogative predicate pronouns, thus clauses using them have no separate copular element.</ref>
* ''cé acu … ?'' – “whether … ?”, “which … ?” (where an alternative is presented)
* ''cé acu … ?'' – “whether … ?”, “which … ?” (where an alternative is presented) <ref group="note" name="cad and cé"/>
 
<div class="warningbox">
'''Note:''' It could be said that the copular is already contained within interrogative predicate pronouns, thus clauses using them have no separate copular element.
</div>


'''Masculine Nouns:'''
'''Masculine Nouns:'''
Line 125: Line 114:
== Notes ==
== Notes ==


# There is no indefinite article in Irish. Without the definite article, ''leabhar'' can mean either “book” or “a book” depending on the context.
<references group="note"/>
# The present negative copular form ''ní'' causes ''h''-prothesis on the following word, hence ''hea''.
# The subject often employs the demonstratives ''seo'', ''sin'' and ''siúd'' – “this”, “that” and “that yonder”, respectively – by combining them with the subject pronoun.
# ''Cad é an rud é sin?'' – this type of question is used when no suggestion is given as to the classification of the object. It can be translated more simply as “what is that thing?”


== Exercises ==
== Exercises ==
Line 154: Line 140:
# This is a match,<sup>2</sup> is it?<sup>3</sup> Yes.
# This is a match,<sup>2</sup> is it?<sup>3</sup> Yes.


'''Notes:'''
'''Hints:'''


<sup>1</sup>''Cad é an rud é?'' (Don't use ''é sin'' or ''é seo'' twice of the same object in two <u>successive</u> questions.)<br/>
<sup>1</sup> ''Cad é an rud é?'' (Don't use ''é sin'' or ''é seo'' twice of the same object in two <u>successive</u> questions.)<br/>
<sup>2</sup>Emphatic position.<br/>
<sup>2</sup> Emphatic position.<br/>
<sup>3</sup>''An ea?''
<sup>3</sup> ''An ea?''

Latest revision as of 20:49, 21 April 2023

Lesson I: Classification Clauses with Masculine Nouns

Key: ⟨copula⟩, ⟨predicate⟩, ⟨subpredicate⟩, ⟨subject⟩, ⟨subsubject⟩.

The copula is the element that links the subject to a predicate. Here, the affirmative form of the copula in the present tense is is.

The predicate is the element that describes the subject. In classification clauses, the predicate is always indefinite; it cannot be a definite noun nor a personal pronoun. Here, the predicate is the masculine noun leabhar – “(a) book” [note 1] – which is the description being used to classify the subject. In copular classification clauses, it is the predicate that carries the syntactical stress.

The subject is the element that is being classified. Unless a specific noun is being used to refer to the subject, it is generally referred to with a pronoun. The pronoun itself conforms to the grammatical gender and number of the predicate, being a direct reference to the predicate itself. Where the predicate consists of a singular masculine noun, the singular masculine disjunctive pronoun é is used for the subject.

Simple Classification Clauses

In simple classification syntax, the indefinite predicate follows immediately after the copula, and precedes the subject CPS:

  • Is leabhar é. – “It is a book.”

To form the present negative in classification syntax, the copular form is used:

  • leabhar é. – “It is not a book.”

To form the present interrogative, an is used:

  • An leabhar é? – “Is it a book?”

A response to such a question doesn't repeat the predicate or subject. Rather, the indefinite subpredicate pronounea – is employed Cp:

  • An leabhar é? – “Is it a book?”
  • Is ea. – “It is.”

The negative response would be:

  • hea. – “It isn't.” [note 2]

Following a negative response, the correct information can be provided with the preceding conjunction ach – “but” CpP:

  • An leabhar é sin? – “Is that a book?” [note 3]
  • hea, ach peann. – “It isn't, but a pen.”

A separate copular element is not employed when the clause is headed by the predicate interrogative pronoun cad and no suggestion is offered as to the classification. in this format, the subsubject pronouné – following the predicate interrogative pronoun – refers directly to an rud in the subject an rud é sin (rud being a masculine noun), while the é in the subject refers to the predicate in question PsS:

  • Cad é an rud é sin? – “What is it, the thing that that is?” [note 4]
  • Is leabhar é. – “It is a book.”

Emphatic Classification Clauses

When responding in the negative, the correct information can be given in response by placing emphasis on the predicate as a means of contrasting with the previously suggested information. This is done by placing the predicate before the copula, placing the indefinite subpredicate pronoun in the original predicate position PCpS:

  • An leabhar é? – “Is it a book?”
  • hea; peann is ea é. – “It isn't; it is a pen.”

Likewise, the true predicate can be emphasised when multiple options are presented in a question. The interrogative predicate pronoun cé acu [note 5] is used to present multiple alternatives in a question, with the conjunction dividing the alternatives:

  • Cé acu leabhar nó peann é seo? – “Which is this, a book or a pen?”
  • Peann is ea é. – “It is a pen.”

If neither alternative is correct, the following format would be used in the response:

  • leabhar ná peann é; lasán is ea é. – “It is neither a book nor a pen; it is a match.”

Alternatively, the correct information can be given in a simple format without emphasis

  • leabhar ná peann é, ach lasán. – “It is neither a book nor a pen, but a match.”

Notes on the forms of emphasis:
Text here

Vocabulary

Forms of the Copula:

Pronouns:

  • é – “he”, “it” (masc.)
  • é seo – “this” (masc.)
  • é sin – “that” (masc.)
  • an rud é – “the thing it is” (masc.)
  • ea – the indefinite subpredicate pronoun
  • cad … ? – “what … ?” [note 8]
  • cé acu … ? – “whether … ?”, “which … ?” (where an alternative is presented) [note 8]

Masculine Nouns:

  • leabhar – “a book”
  • peann – “a pen”
  • peann luaidhe – “a pencil”
  • bosca – “a box”
  • bord – “a table”
  • lasán – “a match”
  • sparán – “a purse”
  • rud – “a thing”

Conjunctions:

  • – “or”
  • – “nor”
  • ní … ná – “neither … nor”
  • ach – “but”

Salutations

  • Dia is Muire dhuit. – “Hello.” (greeting to one person)
  • Dia is Muire dhíbh. – “Hello.” (greeting to multiple people)
  • Dia is Muire dhuit is Pádraig. – “Hello.” (response to one person)
  • Dia is Muire dhíbh is Pádraig. – “Hello.” (response to multiple people)
  • Slán agat. – “Goodbye.” (said to one person staying)
  • Slán agaibh. – “Goodbye.” (said to multiple people staying)
  • Slán leat. – “Goodbye.” (said to one person leaving)
  • Slán libh. – “Goodbye.” (said to multiple people leaving)

Notes

  1. There is no indefinite article in Irish. Without the definite article, leabhar can mean either “book” or “a book” depending on the context.
  2. 2.0 2.1 The present negative copular form causes h-prothesis on the following word, hence hea.
  3. The subject often employs the demonstratives seo, sin and siúd – “this”, “that” and “that yonder”, respectively – by combining them with the subject pronoun.
  4. Cad é an rud é sin? – this type of question is used when no suggestion is given as to the classification of the object. It can be translated more simply as “what is that thing?”
  5. The prepostional pronoun acu refers to the presented alteratives, cé acu generally translating to “which of these is it”.
  6. The present affirmative form of the copula is often dropped in speech, e.g. leabhar é – “it is a book”.
  7. The present interrogative form of the copula – an – should not be confused with an, a form of the definite article, e.g. an rud – “the thing”.
  8. 8.0 8.1 It could be said that the copular is already contained within interrogative predicate pronouns, thus clauses using them have no separate copular element.

Exercises

Exercises I and IV from Lesson I of the book are intended for the practical classroom environment and are thus not applicable here.

Exercise II:

Translate into English:

  1. Cad é an rud é sin? Is leabhar é.
  2. An leabhar é sin? Ní hea; lasán is ea é.
  3. Cé acu bosca nó sparán é seo? Sparán is ea é.
  4. Cé acu leabhar nó lasán é sin? Ní leabhar ná lasán é, ach peann.
  5. An peann é sin? Is ea.
  6. An bosca é seo? Ní hea, ach bord.

Exercise III:

Translate into Irish:

  1. This is not a pen; it is a pencil.
  2. Is that a pencil? Yes. Is this? No.
  3. What is it?1 A book.
  4. Is that a book? No, but a box.
  5. Whether is this a box or a purse? It's a purse.
  6. This is a match,2 is it?3 Yes.

Hints:

1 Cad é an rud é? (Don't use é sin or é seo twice of the same object in two successive questions.)
2 Emphatic position.
3 An ea?